Convictions vs. Opinions: Discussion Starters

by | Aug 20, 2025 | Man in the Mirror Blog

Do you have strong convictions? Are you willing to “go along to get along,” or are there hills you would die on? What about your opinions? Are they subject to change should new information come along, or resolute, even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary? Here are discussion starters about your convictions vs. opinions.


By the Man in the Mirror Team

What do you think about this quote from Brett Clemmer?

Have strong convictions, and hold them tightly.
Have strong opinions, but hold them loosely.
For one is about how you live, and the other how you learn.

Forward the statement to a friend and ask what they think, or talk about it with a small group.

Below are eight related questions to further help you shape a meaningful conversation about convictions vs. opinions. You may also reflect on them individually and capture your thoughts in a journal.

Convictions vs. Opinions

“Have strong convictions, and hold them tightly. Have strong opinions, but hold them loosely. For one is about how you live, and the other how you learn.” – Brett Clemmer

  1. What are some of your core convictions?
  2. How do convictions give your life structure? Meaning? Direction? Stability?
  3. Have you ever had any of your convictions questioned or challenged? What happened?
  4. Should you have strong opinions? Why or why not?
  5. What are the advantages of holding your opinions loosely?
  6. How might holding your opinions loosely lead to learning, growth, and relationship?
  7. What is the connection between conviction and faith? Between opinion and faith?
  8. How would you relate the following Scriptures to the quote?

Habakkuk 2:4; Psalm 106:35; Proverbs 12:1; 1 Corinthians 2:5; 1 Corinthians 16:13-14; Galatians 1:10; Proverbs 18:2

Recent Posts

This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things

This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things

A German guy named “Freddy” came to America for the World Cup, and for about 2 weeks he was the happiest man on the internet. He followed his team across the country with 2 friends and a rental car. He tried ranch dressing. He walked into an American cathedral named...

read more
A Self-Serving Sexual

A Self-Serving Sexual

**This article was originally published for The Long Middle on Substack** Guys, we finally did it! We’ve climbed the whole pyramid. Food, shelter, safety, belonging, esteem. Maslow drew the hierarchy and we spent a century clawing up it, and now a lot of us in America...

read more
Why Every Man Needs a Mentor in Faith

Why Every Man Needs a Mentor in Faith

Some of us have adopted the mistaken notion that true manhood means hoisting ourselves up by our own bootstraps and manifesting our spiritual and personal goals with only our strength and determination to sustain us. Many of us push forward on our own, white-knuckled,...

read more
We Always Marry the Wrong Person

We Always Marry the Wrong Person

**This article was originally published for The Long Middle on Substack** We always marry the wrong person. God does too. The biggest difference? I didn’t know what I was getting into and God did. Stanley Hauerwas said the real work of marriage is learning to love and...

read more
Skip to content